This is seriously so simple that it hardly warrants a tutorial - paper mache letters and spray paint and done.
The Crate and Barrel letters are 8 inches tall, 1.75 inches deep, and made of a iron with a red finish. Hobby Lobby sells 8 inch tall paper mache letters that are 1 inch deep that are regularly priced at $3, but which I purchased on sale for only $1.50 each. All I needed to give these paper mache letters the same look as the Crate and Barrel originals was a can or red gloss spray paint.
It took me only a minute or two to paint one side of the letters, and when they were dry I flipped them over and painted the other side.
I am thrilled with this new addition to my holiday decor, and at a total cost of only $15 dollars, I saved 75%, which makes me even happier!
Looking for more holiday inspiration?! Here are some of my favorite Christmas projects: